Handvo vs. Dhokla: Key Differences and When to Choose Each
Gujarati cuisine is renowned for its variety of flavorful, nutritious, and versatile dishes. Among them, Handvo and Dhokla are two iconic savory cakes that hold a special place in every Gujarati household. Though they might appear similar, Handvo and Dhokla have distinct ingredients, preparation methods, and occasions when they shine best. Let’s dive into the key differences and when to choose each.
What is Handvo?
Handvo is a savory cake made from a batter of lentils and rice, often mixed with grated vegetables like bottle gourd (lauki). It is traditionally prepared by steaming or baking and has a crunchy crust due to the tempering of mustard and sesame seeds.
- Texture: Dense, slightly crumbly, with a crispy crust.
- Taste: Savory and spicy with earthy undertones from the lentils.
- Best Served With: Green chutney, garlic chutney, or ketchup.
Key Ingredients in Handvo:
- Rice and mixed dals (lentils such as chana dal, urad dal, toor dal)
- Grated vegetables (bottle gourd, carrots, or zucchini)
- Yogurt for fermentation
- Tempering with mustard seeds, sesame seeds, and curry leaves
What is Dhokla?
Dhokla is a steamed, fluffy savory snack made primarily from fermented chickpea flour (besan) or a mix of rice and urad dal. Known for its light, airy texture, Dhokla is a versatile dish that can be enjoyed for breakfast, snacks, or even as a party appetizer.
- Texture: Soft, spongy, and fluffy.
- Taste: Slightly tangy with a hint of sweetness.
- Best Served With: Sweet tamarind chutney or spicy green chutney.
Key Ingredients in Dhokla:
- Besan (chickpea flour) or fermented rice and dal batter
- Yogurt or lemon juice for tanginess
- Baking soda or Eno for fluffiness
- Tempering with mustard seeds, curry leaves, and green chilies
Key Differences Between Handvo and Dhokla
1. Base Ingredient
- Handvo: Made from a combination of rice and lentil batter.
- Dhokla: Made from besan (chickpea flour) or fermented rice-dal batter.
2. Texture
- Handvo: Dense and slightly crumbly with a crispy crust.
- Dhokla: Light, airy, and spongy.
3. Taste Profile
- Handvo: Savory, spicy, and earthy.
- Dhokla: Tangy, mildly sweet, and soft.
4. Preparation Method
- Handvo: Typically baked or steamed.
- Dhokla: Always steamed.
5. Vegetable Use
- Handvo: Includes grated vegetables like lauki (bottle gourd).
- Dhokla: Rarely includes vegetables.
6. Serving Style
- Handvo: Ideal as a meal or filling snack.
- Dhokla: Perfect as a light snack or appetizer.
7. Occasion
- Handvo: Great for festive meals or hearty snacks.
- Dhokla: Suited for breakfast, tea-time snacks, or party platters.
When to Choose Handvo?
- Hearty Snack or Meal: Handvo is more filling and works well as a light dinner or an evening snack.
- Healthy Option: With its blend of lentils, rice, and vegetables, it’s a protein-packed, fiber-rich dish.
- Festive Gatherings: The crunchy texture and rich flavors make it a great addition to festive spreads.
When to Choose Dhokla?
- Quick Snack: Dhokla is a light and quick-to-prepare option for breakfast or tea-time snacks.
- Party Favorite: Its soft and spongy texture makes it easy to serve as finger food at parties.
- Diet-Friendly: Low in calories, Dhokla is perfect for those looking for a light, healthy snack.
Tips for Perfect Handvo and Dhokla
- Fermentation: Ensure the batter ferments well for both dishes to achieve the best texture and flavor.
- Tempering: A good tempering of mustard seeds, sesame seeds, and curry leaves enhances the taste of both Handvo and Dhokla.
- Serving: Serve Handvo hot for the best crunch and Dhokla slightly warm to enjoy its fluffy texture.
Conclusion
While Handvo and Dhokla share some similarities, they are distinct in ingredients, texture, and taste. Handvo is hearty and robust, while Dhokla is light and fluffy. Choose Handvo for a filling snack or meal, and opt for Dhokla when you’re in the mood for a light, tangy treat.
For more Gujarati recipes and food insights, visit AllBlogs—your ultimate guide to authentic cuisine and more!
